×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

(OP)
I'm supplying 480/277 3PH 4Wire power to a new MCC (600A).  I'm still a "rookie" engineer so please bear with me. What are the advantages/disadvantages of routing parallel phase conductors rather than a single phase conductor?  Is it simply less expensive?  Or is it some how "better" than routing one conductor per phase?  Thanks in advance for any advice.

Sense

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

As soon as you have more than one cond/phase, you have to manage the issue of current sharing, with special attention paid to wire lengths and connection impedances.

However, it is much easier (i.e. cheaper) to achieve required ampacities with parallel runs.  The limiting factor in cable ampacities is heat dissipation, and doubling the gauge of a wire will often only add 25% or so to its ampacity, as heat loss is a function of surface area, not cross-sectional area.

Look at the NEC (or CEC) tables for ampacities, and you'll see what I mean.

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Another reason to select multiple conductors rather than a larger single conductor is ease of training the cable.  A large conductor can be more difficult to bend.  For example, bare conductors used to connect substation equipment to bus.

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Upto a certain size its a matter of economics. Generally electricians do not like to handel larger than 500kcmil or 600kcmil condcutors and 4 inch conduit,as jnims said. So it is constructibility and ease of handling issue.

Other fact is the ampacity does not increase proportinal to the size. A condutor with a cross sectional doule than other does not necessarioy carry double current but less than that. Which due to skin effect, for large diameter solid conductor most current will flow in outer area and not the center. This also has to do with heat dissipation capacity. as tinfoil suggested.



RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

 
From a practical aspect, two conductors/ø would do for 600 amperes.
  

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Remember if you are going to run parallel phase conductors in three different conduits, i.e. underground duct bank, do not run all of your A-phase in one conduit, then B-phase in the next conduit etc.  You must mix the phases, i.e. ABC conductors in one conduit, then the next set of parallel conductors should be ABC, etc.  (for three conductor parallel runs).

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Someone told me that the lengths of paralleled cable is very critical. They mentioned that the lengths of the parallel runs needs to be with mm of each other. I did not question this but seems this is an exaggeration. Anyone care to comment?

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

buzzp,

I think the shorter the run, the more critical the length is.  In very short runs, the difference in length, flux linkage, etc between the conductors becomes a much larger part of the total impedance of each conductor.  

For long runs, the slight differences in length become much less significant.

Also keep in mind that if one of the conductor draws more current than the rest, it will increase in temperature and this will increase its resistance.  This effect does help mitigate **some** the length difference.  

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Wouldn't there be a tendency for parallel conductors in close proximity to try to balance the current due to mutual coupling effects?  Of course, if they are that close, you would lose out on the thermal capacity gains.

Bung
Life is non-linear...

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

dpc,
I understand the logic behind equal lengths (equal sharing) but do you suppose mm's (say 3mm) difference in length would make any noticeable difference with cables ran, say 50-100 ft.?

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

The current in each conductor of a parallel set it very closely related to the percentage change in length.  If you have one at 49' and another at 51', the 49' length will carry about 51% of the load and the 51' length will carry about 49% of the load.  
Don

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

Okay, so the millimeters making a difference on even a 5' parallel length is hogwash, as I suspected.

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

I don't think a difference of millimeters is going to make much difference at all in the distribution of current.  Most problems develop from contact resistance at terminations.  If one termination is a little loose or corroded, the other conductors will see a big increase in current.  

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

when using parallel conductors and carrying large currents supporting critical loads I see circuits now use CT tecnology to monitor the currents in each conductor so that any unbalance between like conductors is picked up quickly and delt with. A large imbalance could over stress a termination and lead quickly to premature failure.

CT's feed an electronic module and the module reads out % imbalance on conductors.

Generally not used but the option would be there if it was needed to configure.

Rugged

RE: Advantages / Disadvantages of Parallel Feeder Conductors

I think I've seen a system somewhere using some kind of back to back connetion of CTs to force current sharing - I don't remember the details.  It was one of those ideas that seemed so obvious at the time that I thought I would not forget it.  And now I have.  But maybe this will jog somebody else's memory?

Bung
Life is non-linear...

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources