×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

(OP)
We are going to install a new sports lights system on an existing ballfield. The existing A/C Panel is a 480, 3ph, 225A. The new load is 160A and after appling the continuous operation factor is 200A (160*1.25).
1. Can I use the existing A/C Panel?
2. It is right that the breakers can be loaded up to a maximum of 80% of his rating? If this is correct, I need help to find were is this rule described.
Thanks.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Refer to articles in NEC describing the following:

1. Panelboards and switchboards
2. Branch Circuits, Feeders and Service etc.

In them you will find this. It IS there, I suggest you find it rather than I. (Grin)

Hint: you can use 100% rating if the assembly is listed for such use.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

(OP)
I have not fouded yet rbulsara.  That's why I'm asking for some help.  Thank you for your response I will keep looking in the NEC this weekend.  Thanks again.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

You will not find that in the NEC. It is found in the MFG spec for breakers. The 125% rule for continuous load is found in various locations in the NEC. IF there is only 160 amps continuous on the panel then you should be able to use it. Take care to balance the load.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Look in article 215, "Feeders".

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Wareagle:

May be you should look up the Code too...:)

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

rbulsara
Perhaps you would be kind and point out the section that says "breakers can be loaded only up to 80% of its rating for continuous loads". It am not asking for the 125% rule. I know where that is in the NEC.
WilsonV's post was "2. It is right that the breakers can be loaded up to a maximum of 80% of his rating? If this is correct, I need help to find were is this rule described."
Please show us where it is in the NEC.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

OK ..when i get back in office next week..

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Look in articles 210 and 240.

What other load is on this existing panel?

Mike Cole

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Goodmorning wilsonv
   I will try and see if I can help provide some information that may be of some help. You did not mention if this panelboard is service equipment, or if it is a feeder providing power for the lighting load. Sometimes that will help lead to the correct article to reference and make a difference in the correct application of an article. This is actually a more difficult question than it used to be. Article 384-16(d)(switchboards and panelboards) of the 1999 NEC stated that the total load on ANY overcurrent device located in the panel could not exceed 80% of the devices rating. Since the code stated "any", this article applied to the rating of the main overcurrent device also. In the 2002 NEC, Article 408 covers switchboards and panel boards. The article covering the 80% rule was purposely omitted from this article. The reason was the fact that when you calculate either feeder or branch circuit overcurrent protection(Articles 210.20(A) and 215.3), you must calculate the continous load at 125%. If the actual load calculation is correct, then there will be no need to further derate the panels ampacity. All that is required of the panelboard is that it has a minimum ampacity rating based on the total connected load as calculated by Article 220. Hope this has helped.      

Bigbillnky,C.E.F.....(Chief Electrical Flunky)

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

(OP)
Thanks to all you.
 bigbillnky, this a Panelboard providing power to the lights.  My interpretation of Article 210.20A is that I can  load a breaker 100% with only noncontinuous load even when the device is not listed to operate 100%. Is this interpretation right?  If is right I have found the answer to my question. Thanks a lot.
rbulsara: Thanks, I understand there is people out there that are trying to get it easy.  All I was asking is where the 80% rule appears.
Wareagle: Thanks for your help and do not worry the load will be balanced.
mc5w: Thank you, the only loads in this panel will be lighting.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

You are absolutely correct with your interpretation of article 210.20A. Sometimes the NEC is not as user friendly as it should be, especially when they change the articles around each code cycle. I'm glad I was able to help!   

Bigbillnky,C.E.F.....(Chief Electrical Flunky)

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

Article 215 has the same wording as 210.20.

Also, 384.16: "The total load on any overcurrent device located in a panelboard shall not exceed 80% of its rating where, in normal operation, the load will continue for three hours or more"
Exception: An assembly, including the overcurrent device, shall be permitted to be used for continuous operation at 100% of it rating where it is listed for this purpose.

Lighting is usually considered to be continous load.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

2003 UL White Book
CIRCUIT BREAKERS, MOLDED-CASE AND CIRCUIT BREAKER ENCLOSURES (DIVQ)PRODUCT TYPE
MAXIMUM LOAD
Unless otherwise marked, circuit breakers should not be loaded to
exceed 80 percent of their current rating, where in normal operation the
load will continue for 3 hours or more.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

alehman
What version of the code are you using? NEC 2002 does not have any instructions regarding the use of a breaker at 80%
of its rating that I see.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

use the crossreference listed for NEC 2002 and 1999. The article no. is changed..

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

rbulsara
WilsonV's origional post was "It is right that the breakers can be loaded up to a maximum of 80% of his rating? If this is correct, I need help to find were is this rule described."
I said that that the 80% rule was not found in the NEC.

You reply was "Wareagle:
May be you should look up the Code too...:)"

Article 215 references the use of the 125% factor. It does not say apply 80% to the breaker rating.
My point is the if Wilson searched the current version 2002
NEC, which I use, he will not find a reference the the 80% factor. As I pointed out the 80 % is found in the 2003 UL White Book
CIRCUIT BREAKERS, MOLDED-CASE AND CIRCUIT BREAKER ENCLOSURES (DIVQ).

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

wareagle:

See alehman's post....and mine following it...

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

wareagle:

OK. Here my research during my lunch..(hate to do that..)

I do owe an apology because of NEC's rearrangement, but it still does not change the requirement of not loading more than 80% unless, the OCPD or assembly is 'listed'  for use at 100% of its rating.

2002 NEC article 408 which replaced 1999 article 384 removed the particular paragraph that used to be 384.16.(d) "coninuous load" , which alehman indicated and I was alluding to.

However, it was a redundant statement to what article 215.2(A), 215.3, 210.19.A and 210.10A in NEC 2002 requires.

215.3 in 2002, do require OCPD also to be sized for 125% of the continuous load. Which is same as not loading it more than 80% unless listed for use at 100%.  

Also continuos load is defined as the load expected to continue more than 3 hours or more.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

(OP)
rbulsara:

Let's say that you have a 100A Breaker, and it's not listed for use at 100%.  You have calculated a non continuous load of 90A,  Can you use the 100A Breaker or do you need to use a 125A Breaker?.  My answer will be that I can use the 100A Breaker, based on Article 215.3

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

wilsonv:

I would agree with your interpretation, if the load is indeed non-continuous, that is it will not last for 3 hours or more.

But if you are saying its sports lights, chances are that they will stay lit for more than 3 hrs.

Other important issue you want to consider is the harmonics, HID lights have quiet a bit harmonics and I have seen 200A breaker tripping on 175A of currents due to harmonics. So besides the strict interpretation of Code, design wisely. Rememner that Code is only there for minimium safety measures, it does not care if your lights go out in the middle of a game.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

(OP)
rbulsbara:

  Yes, lights will be treated as a continuous load.  The actual total load will be 157A. Applying the continuous operation factor the calculated load is 197A.  The main breaker on the existing panel is 225A.  It should work with no problems.
  My doubt was appling the 80% rule.  I was thinking that a 225A can be loaded up to 180A (the 80% of 225). I was double derating the breaker, applying the 125% factor and limiting the breaker to an 80% use.

Thanks everybody for your help on this "simple..." matter.

RE: Max. Ckt. Breaker Load

I agree with this conclusion.

Sorry for the confusing NEC reference in my earlier post. That was based on the 1999 code. In 2002, the 80% rule has been removed completely from the panelboard section and remains in articles 210, 215, 220 and 230 where it is stated as "125 percent of continuous load plus 100 percent of noncontinuous load...". It actually is somewhat simpler than 1999.

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources