×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound
4

Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

(OP)
We install a great deal of threaded gas pipe, and use hemp and boss white as a sealing compound on all threaded joints.
Recently I have been made aware that this practise is frowned upon. Is this the case and if so why? What compounds would you recomend?
Many thanks

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

topgun67:

What part of the world are you in?

BobPE

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

(OP)

We are based in the UK

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

2
What the heck is "boss white"?  That's a regional term I've never heard before...

The practice of using "plumber's putty" (principally limestone powder in linseed oil) sometimes combined with jute or hemp twine, went out of style about 50+ years ago here.  It's a tough sealant but not very forgiving- it has near zero elasticity, low lubricity to prevent galling, and you need a torch to get the parts disassembled (even after they start leaking).  In my experience it's poor sealant choice and fitting practice which is responsible for much of the bad reputation that threaded piping has in industry.  

For low pressure utility gas lines, there are a number of approved sealants in North America but the most popular is full-density (i.e. unstretched, s.g. ~1.3-1.5) teflon tape, often dyed yellow to distinguish it as being suitable for gasfitting.

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

(OP)
Hi moltenmetal.
Thanks for your reply. Do you know if the tape you describe has a trade name?  
Many thanks

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

Gas and other codes can vary quite a bit, between jurisdictions. Things like Teflon tape (and other materials) for gas service are permitted in some places, but not others. There are a whole variety of Teflon tapes, pipe dopes, etc for pipe threads, and they'll have what services they're good for, the range of pipe sizes, etc on the can or package. They'll also list any approvals by regulatory bodies that they may have. Some dopes  are only rated up to 1-1/2" pipe, many others to 2". Always important to know what's approved by code in your jurisdiction & to read the label and/or instruction sheet for the particular product.

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

topgun67:

What moltenmetal is advising is what I would also recommend.  However, my experience with Teflon tape goes back for over 40 years and I don't have any problems with it - as long as I install it personally.  I would not trust someone else doing it when I'm not looking.  The reason is that many, many persons just don't apply the tape correctly and it winds up getting shredded and torn inside the piping itself, winding up under some flow obstacle - like a valve, regulator, or other instrument.  This effect plays havoc with the expected operation and gas flows and is an expensive task to locate and remove.

For the above reason, Teflon Paste, a very efficient and effective sealant was developed.  I would recommend you try this out if you are going to delegate the thread sealing to others that you can't supervise personally.

I hope this experience helps.

Art Montemayor
Spring, TX

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

Boss white is or was white lead. This is from my little red maintenance handbook circa 1950. The present formulation is probably has different ingredients.

Lead oxide in triple boiled linseed oil or linseed oil and tallow is very good pipe dope.  At one time this was the universal pipe dope.  It was used in all services.

We used hemp or jute packing saturated with some oil ?? and beeswax/tallow on water pumps.  

I’ve seen variation of various fibers combined with lead and it’s oxides combined under various trade names, the one I remember is “ALL PACK” for valves.       

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

There are definitely jurisdictional and regional codes and standards that apply for gasfitting- too many to mention.  Make sure you follow them, as insurance companies love to deny claims from people who break the local rules.  

As to brand names of teflon tape, there are many, but the ones I'm familiar with here in North America are likely not available for sale in the UK.  Just make sure that if you use teflon tape, it's the full- or near-full density material.  In our experience, we get good performance with tapes of s.g. 1.0 and higher- 1.5 s.g. is not completely necessary.  Some teflon tapes have been expanded or stretched to a specific gravity as low as 0.25, though the nominal thickness of the tape can be the same as for the denser tapes.  The stretched materials are often sold in hardware stores for general-purpose plumbing and are often either brilliant white or dyed a peach/orange colour.  These tapes are seldom approved for use in gasfitting.

If you're using teflon tape only, care in installation and proper threading practice is key to a good joint.  Poorly installed tape is useless and can clog downstream equipment, and in some jurisdictions tape is banned from a certain point in the line onward (for fear it jams a gas shutoff valve in the open position at some time in future).

Modern anaerobic paste pipthread sealants (aka "pipe dopes") are far superior to the previous generation of lead-and limestone- based sealants, though plenty of those can still be had.  Some of the modern pastes contain particles of teflon, and some don't- in our experience the teflon particles are superfluous and other, cheaper fillers work just as effectively.  

Our general-purpose solution for threaded piping is a Henkel Loktite brand anaerobic paste on top of teflon tape.  With this combination, leaks are a rarety even when using cheap Chinese 150# threaded fittings.  Some services require either tape alone (generally for purity reasons or where the acrylate resins in the paste are attacked), or paste alone (ie. for instrument air between a filter and a sensitive device like an I/P converter).

RE: Gas pipe / Hemp as a sealing compound

(OP)
Guys

Many thanks for your advice. Am now in the process of trying to source the above mentioned materials. If I have any problems I may ask for further help

Thank you

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources