Very unique??
Very unique??
(OP)
Is it improper to add a modifier to the term unique, or is just being unique as singular as it gets?
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS Come Join Us!Are you an
Engineering professional? Join Eng-Tips Forums!
*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail. Posting GuidelinesJobs |
|
RE: Very unique??
Ed
RE: Very unique??
...UNUSUAL (we were fairly unique, the sixty of us, in that there wasn't one mixer in the bunch)-J.D.Salinger; (a very unique ball-point pen).
The dictionary continues in demonstrating that the modification, as by very, somewhat, almost, of unique is correct.
RE: Very unique??
Is it then sensible to ask if something is uniquely unique?
Ed,
Hey, Its New Years day and I'm Scottish
RE: Very unique??
Look at the logic of it.
Ball point pens. Everybody knows there are a great many different ball point pens.
Ahh, but a unique ball point pen!
Hypothetical examples:
1)A great man autographs one (and only one) ball point pen. No doubt, that pen is unique. Now is it logical to embelish unique with truly unique, splendidly unique, absoloutely unique? Perhaps, if it were going to auction.
2) The same great man this time once and only once autographs a batch of ball point pens. Now in this case the entire batch could be called unique. However, no longer could any individual pen qualify as unique. They could qualify as rare. Fairly unique seems inappropriate.
HAPPY NEW YEAR
RE: Very unique??
http://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=89559
RE: Very unique??
Part of our problem as a society is that we don't have room for grey. A great example is "you are either with us or against us". BS !!!
I think there is room for modifiers to unique.
RE: Very unique??
So, now it seems (to me at least) that the proper use of the term unique only applies to a one of a kind or singular occurrence and to add a modifier is to add excessive verbiage. I think the slightly pregnant example sewed it up.
I tend disagree with the black/white and lack of grey argument. I now think a different word should be used if embellishment is desired, or perhaps don't try to asign a color to something that is clear.
RE: Very unique??
No need to apologize to me. I thought I'd seen it discussed earlier and simply siezed the opportunity to make a wisecrack...
RE: Very unique??
RE: Very unique??
Come on guys - try to keep up!
We hashed it out in Thread1010-89559 !
Good Luck
johnwm
________________________________________________________
To get the best from these forums read FAQ731-376 before posting
UK steam enthusiasts: www.essexsteam.co.uk
RE: Very unique??
USAGE NOTE For many grammarians, unique is the paradigmatic absolute term, a shibboleth that distinguishes between those who understand that such a term cannot be modified by an adverb of degree or a comparative adverb and those who do not. These grammarians would say that a thing is either unique or not unique and that it is therefore incorrect to say that something is very unique or more unique than something else. Most of the Usage Panel supports this traditional view. Eighty percent disapprove of the sentence Her designs are quite unique in today's fashions. But as the language of advertising in particular attests, unique is widely used as a synonym for worthy of being considered in a class by itself, extraordinary and if so construed it may arguably be modified. In fact, unique appears as a modified adjective in the work of many reputable writers. A travel writer states that “Chicago is no less unique an American city than New York or San Francisco,” for example, and the critic Fredric Jameson writes “The great modern writers have all been defined by the invention or production of rather unique styles.” Although these examples of the qualification of unique are defensible, writers should be aware that such constructions are liable to incur the censure of some readers. See Usage Notes at absolute, equal, infinite.
RE: Very unique??
A friend of mine once combined "verbiage" and "garbage" to coin the term "varbage." I like it. (I doubt that a definition is needed here.)
RE: Very unique??
If you use it in any other way, I think that unique then takes on the role of being a modifier or a lazy writers usage as a replacement for another word.
Naresuan University
Phitsanulok
Thailand