Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Important Applicant Skills, revisited
(OP)
To add fuel to my previous post, I would like to toss in modern grammer, or the lack of it. Do you judge the applicant by their command of the spoken language?
Take a look at this:
"Me and her gone to the store." Followed by "Me and him done this."
ARGGGHHH!
When I listen to what I think is a skilled professional and this simple comment comes out, they lose all credibility with me. Am I alone? I am told I am too critical, that this is the way people talk today (sorry, not me).
Choose your language of choice, I am sure it is universal.
Franz
Take a look at this:
"Me and her gone to the store." Followed by "Me and him done this."
ARGGGHHH!
When I listen to what I think is a skilled professional and this simple comment comes out, they lose all credibility with me. Am I alone? I am told I am too critical, that this is the way people talk today (sorry, not me).
Choose your language of choice, I am sure it is universal.
Franz
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.





RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
To me, there's a some notion that a good engineer does not stop at simply getting an answer, but also understanding of why? and what the correct answer should be. This means that he should be using English properly.
Additionally, using English incorrecly during presentations could certainly diminish the quality and acceptability of one's presentations.
TTFN
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
My high school physics teacher would base part of our lab grades on organization and penmanship. Her point was that in our future professional lives, most of our peers' and customers' first and strongest impressions of us would be from our writing.
I haven't forgotten. Here's to you, Mrs. Westphal.
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Hours of fun for the typists.
Their reason was, if there's a spelling mistake in a word that indicates a lack of proofreading, admittedly corrigible by context. But what happens to a typo in a number? The final reader cannot easily check whether it should have been 1372.4 or 1327.4
Cheers
Greg Locock
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
HVAC68
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Thread1010-104704
("writing quality" thread in the English forum)
[tangent]
I've wondered about that "me & him" construction a lot. Why is it that people will say "me & him went" when they won't say "me went" or "him went"? I don't really hear that much from adults; I remember getting corrected for saying it myself when I was little. What I do hear a lot from adults, and drives me nuts, is the hypercorrection that puts "I" in object position (like "Send it to Joe or I"). Though from a linguistic standpoint even that one is fascinating, because it's a hypercorrection of the very tendency franzh talks about, and so in a way just further reinforces the reality of that particular construction. I have just now written a linguist to ask. I shall somehow refrain from posting my findings here.
[/tangent]
Hg
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
"Me and him done this."
Errr... this is either due to a spectacular lack of grammar skills, I would almost say a blind spot in the brain,
or a spectacular lack of interest in how a sentence is supposed to be constructed.
If this interest in how things are supposed to be constructed extends itself beyond sentences toward objects, I would be hesitant to let this person engineer my project.
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Regards,
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
If the schools don't teach these skills (and many don't) then you'll have a clear indication that an applicant is a "self starter" who can master skills in spite of the school system if they speak and write well.
Both of my sons went through school systems that had de-emphasized grammar and spelling. Both (finally) decided that they didn't like being grouped with the illiterate lumps of their generation and have taken steps on their own to overcome the handicap of a lousy education. Now they both speak fairly well and can get close enough to a correct spelling for Bill Gates to guess the word they want to use. I believe that these efforts will (and should) be rewarded in the job market.
David
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
I worked with more than a few foreign-born engineers that have an outstanding command of written English, enough to embarrass many natives.
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
me & him = we
me & him went
TTFN
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Accusatives R us. I mean, "us" is accusative.
Hg
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
However, poor grammer in one's native tongue is indicative of a number of things, none flattering.
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
So it becomes more like choice of clothing. Most people whose everyday speech is not that of the status group are perfectly capable of using the status dialect when they need to, especially if they're well-educated and have had plenty of contact in circles that speak the status dialect. If they haven't picked up by the time they're on the job market that there is in fact a status form of speech (and writing), they haven't been paying attention or don't care (or are making a form of political statement). It may not be fair that their dialect isn't the one that's considered "correct", but that's irrelevant in business.
Hg
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
I am Portuguese and I think my English is not the worst I've seen around. A good thing is that in my country we use subtitles and very few engineering books are translated to my native tongue, so I get some advantage from it. :D
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Well... yes, you made a good point there if there's a language (which I'm not familiar with, I guess) in which "me and him" is correct.
As a matter of fact (undermining my earlier post even further), I think it's equally desirable that engineers be able to not only speak "properly" but also be able to express themselves in redneck or whatever the local dialect may be, to be a credible discussion partner for any local slang speakers "out there in the plant".
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Manager: "The project has to be finished and ready to present by Monday, no matter what."
Translater to Geek: "We need more power to the engines, Scotty! You'll have to stay until we get it."
Geek to Translater: "Aye, Cap'n, but we need more dilithium crystals!"
Translater to Manager: "He wants overtime pay."
"Eat well, exercise regularly, die anyways."
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Hg
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
TTFN
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
That is 'sup dawg...you are showing your age dare I say....LOL
BobPE
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
TTFN
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
I've always been technically inclined, and as typical with many of us, suffered from a combination of not caring about writing, and being "grammar challenged".
It was about a year after college that I got I finally got “IT” through my thick skull; “IT” being that the technical content of what I wrote wasn’t even read if it wasn’t written properly, with ZERO error!
I’m still not the world’s greatest writer, but even I will notice “minor” errors in reports, findings, and resumes. These matter to me. More importantly, they matter to my customers. I therefore always query hiring candidates on their writing aptitude, and find an excuse to require them to provide a writing sample (one that wasn’t prepared ahead of time by someone else).
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
Do you really need them to do on-the-spot writing, though? Asking for a report that THEY have prepared should be the same as asking for a design that THEY have done, and the same suspicion or lack thereof about outside help should apply. What kind of assignments do you give? Do they actually have to sit & write longhand?
Hg
RE: Important Applicant Skills, revisited
I'll ask them to provide a sample of their writing, in a day or two by email. I will accept a previously written report as long as the candidate is the primary authore (knowing I have no way to verify this); but I prefer they write something short but new, such as a one page (MAX) description of a project that I (as an outsider) can understand.
If I get a well written summary in a day or two, I know the candidate can write. If I get a poorly written summary in a week or two, I don't hire.