×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

US Specification of Concrete Strengths
2

US Specification of Concrete Strengths

US Specification of Concrete Strengths

(OP)
Simple Question

Are design strengths of concrete in the US based on Cylinder Strength or Cube Crushing Strength.

I am doing some fairly simple design work for a friend building his own house in the US (I am in the UK). The concrete strength he quoted me (3000psi = 20N/m2) seems low compared to what we would use in the UK for reinforced concrete (At least 30N/mm2 = 4500psi)

Thanks in advance

Jon

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

Cylinder strength at 28 days is standard.

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

Oh...  3000 psi is a typical compressive strength we specify here in the US.  If we need higher strength, we may go 4000 psi, 4500 psi, etc.  I have not specified higher than 5000 psi so far.

If the volume of work is small, why not specify 4500 psi if it will make you feel more comfortable.  Cost impact won't be too significant...

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

For house construction in the US - 3000 psi is very much the standard.

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

Is there a reason why the UK uses a much higher typical strength concrete than the US?  Is it maybe environmental or some other concern, code requirement, or is that just how they do it across the pond?

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

The 30 N/mm2 cube strength quoted is approx. equal to 3600 psi cylinder strength, so the strength increase is not  as large as it first appears.
The british concrete code BS8110 lists 30 N/mm2 as the lowest grade required to achieve adequate durability for 'mild' exposure classification ie. concrete protected against weather or aggressive conditions  (Tables 3.2 & 3.3).

John

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

Just for those who haven't caught it in other threads - the rule of thumb to convert cube strength to cylinder strength is:

       cube strength times 0.8  = cylinder strength
   cylinder strength times 1.25 = cube strength

This is a rule of thumb - actually there is variation depending on the strengths involved. According to Shetty the ratio of cylinder to cube is in the order of 0.9 for cube strengths greater than 30MPa - 0.8 is good for cube strengths of less than 25 or so. Others have a slightly different take on this.  There is one older thread that gives some BS standard details on this aspect - sorry I don't have the thread number handy - may try a search.

(Shetty Concrete Technology Theory and Practice 5th Revised Edition 2002)
  

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

For one and two story homes:

The IBC (I am looking at the Residential Code of New York Stated which is part of the IBC code group but has maps and figures relating to the entire US ) states that even less compressive strength is required to comply with the code's min requirements:

Table 402.2
2500 psi for foundations not exposed to the weather.........
based upon weathering probabilites in the US

The code has a map of the US with 3 different weathering probability areas, Severe  (northern tier of US), Moderate (southern states such as North Carolina, most of Oklahoma and New Mexico, and Negliglble areas (Florida, southern Texas, Southern California.  But 2500 psi is good for all three for the "not exposed" case.

This code also states 3500 psi for severe areas of the US for specific areas such as porches, carports and garage floor slabs, and steps exposed to the weather

So, it depends on which State!

But go with 3000 psi, it is standard, except for the specific areas stated above where 3500 psi is required, and provided that the specific location uses the IBC Code.


 


 

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

Just remember something when designing homes... every concrete truck which is turned away at an inspector controled site (say a commercial, industrial or government job) usually ends up at a residential site where there is no inspector. If you specify too high a concrete strength you might not get what you want. Hire an inspector for some quality control...

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

(OP)
Thanks for the responses - The confirmation that the US uses cylinder strength as the basis for specifying concrete was what I needed to know.

It is curious that even accounting for the Cylinder Strength - Cube strength conversion, Concrete in the US appears to be generally weaker than in the UK.

Cheers

J

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

jonse...It would appear that the British Standards, relative to the US Standards, place a greater emphasis on durability rather than compressive strength.  Glad to see that.  I have long been a proponent that if you design concrete mixes for the durability required for the application, compressive strength becomes a benefit, not a requirement.

While the minimum standard in the UK might be a bit higher than the minimum in the US, both are adequate, by historical performance, for the application.

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

On many commercial and industrial jobs contractors have other things to do besides waiting for concrete compressive strength to come up to spec. Bids are often prepared with a mix design that meets spec in 10 to 14 days (instead of the 28 day standard). The result is concete that has signicantly higher "design" compressive strength than required.

There are sometimes reasons to consider limiting MAXIMUM compressive strength (within reason). More cement in the mix - more shrinkage - more tendancy to crack. I have heard of this being done for applications such as unreinforced sidewalks (in mild climates).

RE: US Specification of Concrete Strengths

jonse - don't think the US concrete is "weaker" - it is just that both countries specify different compressive strengths for a similar application.  Sort of like the dollar and the pound sterling.  When I go to McDonalds in the US I pay 4.59 or so for a Quarter Pounder Meal Deal - in London, I paid 4.29 or so for the same thing.  Does that make the US dollar stronger?  Couldn't see someone in US paying nearly US$8 at McDonalds for one deal meal - maybe in 10 years!

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources