×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
I am going to be destroking a quad cam V6 soon and I am concerned about this engines history of spun rod bearings. The bearing speed will be lower due to the offset grinding to destroke it. I would assume that itself would help some. I was considering having additional notches cut in the rods and caps at the separation line and modifying the bearings so they have 4 tangs total per rod rather than 2. I noticed this on some of the alluminum top fuel rods I have seen. I would think that would have to help, but I would like the oppinion of some others with more knowledge about this. Any info or ideas is appreciated.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

If the bearing crush, clearance and journal shape and finish are correct and there is adequate supply of a suitable quality oil, bearing should not spin with only one tag per bearing.

Check crush. Check clearance. Check ovality, taper and finish of the journal. Check the bearings have sufficient extra clearance across the parting line so not as to wipe the journal clean of oil as the cap distorts at high rpm. Check side clearance.

Check oil pressure for at absolute minimum of 10 psi per 1000 rpm hot.

Use premium grade synthetic oil.

Make sure the pick up is always under good air free oil under all operating conditions.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Additional tangs will do little to hold a rod bearing from spinning. They are there for locating the bearing side to side position and to align with the rod/cap parting line. Most bearings are manufactured with a larger I.D. across the parting line as oppossed to the size measured 90 deg. from that. Premium rod/cap fasteners torqued or stretched to manufacturers spec. is good insurance. Pat's advice about oil pressure is right on. As a suggestion you might do well to run mineral based oil for the break in period and switch over to the synthetic after. Synthetics lube so well it delays the ring to cylinder wall seating. With proper crush and an adequate oil wedge between the journal and bearing, you won't run into any problems.---------Phil   P.S. Good assembly hygene is also crtical. Any dirt that somehow may find its way into the oil supply is a killer.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Another idea I DON'T like is when guys completely fill the oil pump with white grease or something similar. They do it so the pump will prime, but it restricts oil flow until it is completely flushed.

If the pump is any good at all, it will only need a slight smear of grease on the gears and internal surfaces swept by the gear to prime instantly. The best way to ensure oil pressure on start up is to have a good pump and spin it up with a drill and an old distributor bottom half and shaft with no gear.

As SMOKEY says. cleanliness is next to godliness when it comes to engine assembly.

Mineral oil will help the rings bed into the bores, but synthetic from the start with new bearings, but rings and bores that are already bedded in as you do not need to bed in bearings.

Are you sure the crank is being linished correctly. The grain raised against the direction of rotation can cause bearings to spin at times.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

MNRaptor:

Pat & Smokey are on the money, is it a problem associated with a particular journal or is it random??

Cross drilling the crank will improve the oil to the rod journals & should be the end of your troubles!

If it is a particular journal all the time further inspection of the oil ways may be in order!

How much oil is going to the top end instead of where it belongs, it may need restricting??

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

which engine is that?

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
Well, to start off, this engine is the Mitsu 6g72 found in the 93 & up stealth and 3000gt with the four bolt main and forged crank. The engines after rebuild have a really common issue with spun bearings. The engine I am building is at 100K and is in perfect condition now with no bearing issues. The crank is getting offset ground undersize to destroke it and use a different rod. The engine is being designed to rev with longer rods 2.14 ratio when done and 1.3:1 oversquare. The dry sump system is almost complete so oiling won't be an issue. The crank finish is also not an issue in this case, it will be taken care of by the best in the St Paul/Minneapolis area, Nitrided after grinding and checked for straightness,OOR etc. The rods are Crowers with ARP's and the bearings will be H rated ACL's. The block machine work is top notch, I have run 16 engines through this place this year and they do amazing work so I have no fear on that end. I always am very anal about everything being clean and tripple checking my clearances etc. So really, I shouldn't be worried, but I am just because of how common an issue this is with these engines. In a similar situation before, I  believed because we are so careful, we wouldn't have the same issues with a specific motor everyone else was having, and it came back to prove me wrong. I just want to cover every possible base this time because I don't like to fail and also this one is mine.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
I missed the cross drilling answer above. We did discuss that, but the crank is already drilled all the way through and adding another hole is not something I feel safe doing. The HP expectations for this engine are pretty high, I don't want to create a new point of failure trying to prevent the other problem.

I guess I am not surprised by the answers above. I did think adding an additional tang may help and seeing it on some of the top fuel rods in my mind supported it. With the additional details I gave, do you all still feel the same? Do you think there is any other way to help prevent this? It is a bad enough problem that most of the 3S owners opt for a new shortblock from the factory as opposed to a rebuild since nobody can seem to overcome this with any consistancy.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

MNRaptor

An extra tang should not be necessary, there is an oil related problem. Are the blocks being line-bored when rebuilding???

What main & big end clearances are you running??

What brand of bearings are you using, are they having problems with the factory bearings or just aftermarket types!

Are the oil holes in the main bearings as large as the oil holes in the main bearing saddles??

Have you tried to feed the mains with seperate oil lines direct from the pump!!

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

MNRaptor:

A couple of things i asked you already stated--DUH!!

The bearings you are using, are they tri-metal bearings or sintered alloy??

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

I cannot see an inherent reason why a new factory short engine should be any better than a used (read seasoned) short engine, so long as nothing is fatigued nor cracked, and so long as suitable quality of preparation and parts are used.

Have you inspected and measured new parts. Do you have specs for new parts, especially bearing shell dimensions and materials.

The bearings do not know if they are in a Chev, a Mitsubishi, A F1, a KB or a Gogomobile. They know what temperatures, oil supply, clearances, loads, dynamic changes to clearances etc they see.

People like Cleveite make a number of different bearings for the one engine, to suit different applications. They do this because it is necessary to optimise different properties for different applications, eg aluminium for long wear at moderate loads, or white metal coated for the ability to wear rather than grab in very high load applications where parts flex so much that clearances are more than used up for an instant.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
The bearings used are all tri-metal. I don't know if the blocks with the bearing issues have been line bored or not, it is just one of those things that seems to be all too common like a crankwalked 7 bolt 4g63. I am probably already fixing the issue with the dry sump, I know there has been issues with  the oil pumps and cavitation. This is just a known issue with this particular engine model so the specifics of what bearing clearances and types as well as what extent they each took the machining is unknown. I would hope that they were all within factory spec for clearances and I would guess the bearings would mostly be from Mitsu since that is the norm with this group but I couldn't say for sure. I am changing so many things about this particular engine that the issues everyone is dealing with probably don't apply. We are probably going to  try to get a shortblock available for these owners that is more reliable than what they have available now so all the info will still help with that. Thanks again for all the info, if any other possibilities are out there, please let me know.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Pat:

If the bearings knew they were in a Gogomobile they'd want out of there!!

Wooden blocks would be fine for them!!

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

But then again, If I was a bearing, the last place I would want to be is in a KB in a Top Fuel car. 2 minutes life, including warm up and burn out.

Come to think of it, I think a Gogomobile is a 2 stroke.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Any verified failures with Mobil 1?  I believe it is remarkable stuff when "design" deficiencies have left me on the edge.

Any verified failures using an oil accumulator?  They are a great band-aid/insurance policy for momentary oil loss.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Also, if the oil accumulator cures the problem, a dry sump as mentioned earlier, should also cure it.

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Another idea I DON'T like is when guys completely fill the oil pump with white grease or something similar. They do it so the pump will prime, but it restricts oil flow until it is completely flushed.--Pat
==========================================================

i know that's probably not your problem ?...but like Pat stated , i would "never" assemble a Race Engine with a "LUBE" i couldn't fillup the pan with and run the engine for 100 miles.   You can't fillup your oil pan with white grease and go run it for 100 miles or so, ..so why would you assemble an engine with white grease (Lithium) ??

How about your Rod Bolt Torque ??
which method are you using to Torque the rod bolts ?
Stretch or Torque ??

i just had an engine builder come to my Shop 2 nites ago with a LS-6 engine in pieces...he used the "Stretch Method"
2 Rods wanted 80 Torque , and all the others wanted around 60 to 63 Torque for same "Stretch"

the 2 that were at 80 TQ didn't fail, and bearings looked like the day you took them out of the box !

all the others at 60 to 63 spun, blackened big ends, and some rods came apart and destroyed the engine

i took one of the rods and it wanted 78 to 80 TQ by "Feel"
pulling with my Torque wrenches, instead of his 60 to 63 by Stretch

make dead-sure your rod halves "don't" have a chamfer on the parting halves....as the bearing tangs can get rounded-off in that chamfer !   The chamfer is death to the bearing tangs...it lets the bearing halves and their tangs move in and out into that area...if the bearing is moving around , it will "blacken" the oil film on back sides and the backs of the bearings will have a faint Skunk or Rear Gear oil smell

never grind a chamfer on rod caps parting lines
the bearing tangs need a dead stop to be against, not a wedge !






Larry Meaux (maxracesoftware@yahoo.com)
Meaux Racing Heads - MaxRace Software
ET_Analyst for DragRacers
Support Israel - Genesis 12:3
http://www.maxracesoftware.com/

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
Thanks again for the info, I build high performance engines just about every day, so the specifics of proper assembly are not really needed, I am probably more anal about assembly than most of the shops you will ever see. I am one of the owners of a performance shop in St Paul MN, dealing with forced induction applications only. I use the stretch method for assembling rods with only ARP fasteners and lube. I have never had one of my engines fail from a spun bearing or any assembly error.  The question mainly was, aside from the correct methods of assembly for a given application,  what would help ensure an engine would have less chance of bearings spinning. The question about adding additional tangs to the bearing and rod was more the type of thing I was interested in. That has been covered by others saying that it would likely be an oil supply/quality related issue causing the bearings to fail on this engine family, and that may be true given the known issues with pump cavitation. The reason I believed that extra tang idea in the bearing and rod had merit was for the same reasons you give for not chamfering the separation line on the rods, the tangs need a positive stop, not a wedge. Why would that matter if it did nothing to help them from spinning? I believe the issues with this engine spinning bearings with the frequency it occurs is a design flaw from the mitsu engineers. Obviously they failed with the oil pump, the engines do spin bearings frequently even from the factory as well(not only from someone's failed rebuild) The bearings are considerably more narrow than most of the Mitsu engines I deal with and the diameter of the bearings are quite a bit larger. Could either of these things contribute to the bearing spinning? The additional speed from the larger diameter?

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

If the problem is limited to rod bearings and is common to this engine design, I would look at the following:

1. The oil groove in the main bearings, as they feed the rods.
2. The design of the rod oil holes in the crank, I'm not familiar with this engine but they may not be well suited to racing engines. Check to see that the main journal opening of the rod oil holes is right on the oil groove in the bearing.

Some people carve scoops into the main journal opening of the rod oil holes with sucess.

Jonathan T. Schmidt
http://www.schmidtmotorworks.com

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Have you looked into the timing of the oiling relative to TDC?  In very high performance applications if the rod bearing is lubricated too early or too late relative to combustion, the oil film is not at its optimum  thickness and thus bearing / journal contact is more likely to occur.

Also look into how that rod journal is getting its oil.  I build performance Sunbeam Alpine motors, and they have a history of spinning #2 and 3 rod bearings.  Turns out that 2 and 3 get their oil from main journal #3 which is also feeding the center journal on the cam as well as the entire upper end of the motor.  Additionally the oil hole on the crank is providing the rod bearing with oil way too early, leaving the oil film too thin when combustion occurs at hight RPM's.  These are the kinds of things that can make or break your motor.

Good luck

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

I would like to know which half of the bearing see's the distress first on this engine? Or has it not been caught in time to see?

Do you have any bearing loading figures?  

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
Thanks Tigretr, that is good info. I hadn't really considered those aspects of the situation, What would be considered optimum for a high RPM application in relationship to TDC?

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

MNRaptor

Can you tell us more about these spun rod bearings? Is it always the same rod journal that spins? Do you have an oiling diagram of this engine? and if so can you post it some where?
Do you still have the damaged bearings and/or rods? I read an article a long time ago which showed how by examing a ruined plain bearing you could tell why it failed (i.e. oil too hot, not enough oil, foreign object damage)

Bye for now

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
As I said before, not an issue I have had personally. I own a speed shop in St Paul and I am building one of these engines for my personal car, but it has not had any bearings spun. The reason I ask about this is that I will be building these engines on a regular basis from here on for customers as well and I want to make sure I do any possible research I can to prevent what for this particular engine style seems to be a real issue based on the amazing number of occurances.  I will see if I can get an oiling diagram, shouldn't be a problem. Also, I will see if I can compile some data as to which bearings are the most common failure. Thanks again for all the help, it is appreciated.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

I completely agree with everyone that has posted, spun bearings are a lack of lubrication issue. The bearing gets hot and sticks to the crank. Adding tangs or other methods would only add a slight insurance factor in a situation where lubrication or rod distortion happened momentarily and the bearing would suffer damage anyway. Adding tangs sounds risky as far as maintaining all the original specs for the bearing. Back in the sixtys we pinned rod bearings in big block chevs with brass pins and the bearing mfgs even had bearings designed for the pins. I'm just mentioning this because it is what you are asking. Pinning the bearings is just a band aid and isnt the answer but it will help in very limited situations.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

The guys that really needed pinned bearings used aluminum rods, which lose some of their initial bearing crush when they get hot.  There were articles showing how British motorcycles with aluminum crankcases and rods could start off with nearly zero bearing clearance on a cold day.  Similarly The Corvair SAE papers plotted some wild main bearing clearances with respect to temperature.

In regard to the  Mitsubishi engine, I wonder if there are some popular modifications that might often accompany the first rebuild and might be inferior to some of the factory parts.  Looser clearances, Hot Rod oil pickups, changing rod bolts without re-sizing the rods, etc.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
The engines being rebuilt havn't had any specific popular mods  that would be responsible for the bearing issue. After digging into this a bit more, I have heard that a lot of them are putting fresh bearings in between 60 and 100K to prevent the issue. With the bearings wearing enough to justify that, I agree the problem lies somewhere in the oiling system. I am getting one that had a bearing spun this week, I will see what I can find from it, maybe there will be something fairly obvious.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

MNRaptor,
The "optimum" position of the oil holes on the rod journal is not necessarily a fixed number of degrees before or after TDC.  The angle of maximum force on the bearing is a function of camshaft, timing, fuel, ... etc and is obviously motor specific. However as a general rule we use a Chevy small block crank as our model for re-drilling cranks.  The key is to make sure oiling is not happening too late.  

I look forward to hearing your report on what you find in this motor coming to you soon.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Since it hasn't been mentioned yet, I've heard that some big end problems are due to the cap ends rotating around the bolt sleeves. This is avoided in some rods by dowel pins either side of the bolts or by a serrated interface between the cap and rod.

I was told (by a Japanese Mitsubishi mechanic in my old rally days) to keep the bearings super clean and dry (after cleaning with solvent) so that the bearings "gripped" properly and transfered heat well.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

OpenSourceCar makes an often overlooked point, i have seen many rod resizing jobs that have the internal bore finish on the rods to coarse & transfering heat away from the bearings is then a problem with high rpm race engines.

Tigretr makes the point about oiling angle, this should not really be an issue because you should have 360deg oiling to the rod journals, if not your not racing & if not you better fix it!

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

Tmoose, you mention Corvair bearing clearances with respect to temperature, do you or anyone else have any information on the VW Aircooled engines?

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

I remember that air cooled VWs had a locating dowel in the main bearings, and that it was essential to check the crush on the mains when reconditioning one. In most cases, the tunnel had to be cut and shut, or oversize OD bearings could also be obtained as to many cut and shuts ended up effecting the distributor drive gear clearance and deck height.

I will have the factory specs buried somewhere in the library if you really need them

Regards
pat   pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

(OP)
The thought of using a cerated interface on the cap is interesting. I have seen top fuel rods that way. I am curious as well if anyone knows what neighborhood the RA should be for the rod's internal bore. We have them resized after changing the bolts to ARP's. I am sure the machine shop we use knows what finish to put on them, but it would be nice to confirm it.

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

If detonation occurs, this can hammer out the bearing. This will lead to bearing failure. The bearing can then spin in the rod. Amazing the number of bearing and crank issues that are caused by detonation. This is about the only thing I can see know one has recommended to watch out for. Hope it helps..

RE: Any input on this idea for reducing spun rod bearings is welcome.

I have seen alot of hydraulic locked engines with majorly bent con rods, with crankshafts that survived it just fine, and bearings also in okay shape from it. I think that is alot more stress than the average detonation causes.
And besides most top fuel engines are pretty much running in a full detonation range.
Hmmm I wonder why those diesel engines don't just kill bearings in a week or so. With that detonation like cetane knock?

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources