×
INTELLIGENT WORK FORUMS
FOR ENGINEERING PROFESSIONALS

Log In

Come Join Us!

Are you an
Engineering professional?
Join Eng-Tips Forums!
  • Talk With Other Members
  • Be Notified Of Responses
    To Your Posts
  • Keyword Search
  • One-Click Access To Your
    Favorite Forums
  • Automated Signatures
    On Your Posts
  • Best Of All, It's Free!
  • Students Click Here

*Eng-Tips's functionality depends on members receiving e-mail. By joining you are opting in to receive e-mail.

Posting Guidelines

Promoting, selling, recruiting, coursework and thesis posting is forbidden.

Students Click Here

Jobs

heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

(OP)
Hi,
I'm trying to nail down a good, cost-effective material for heating a vat containing sodium hypochlorite, for the purpose of membrane cleaning.  The temperature is only going to be up to 30 degrees Centigrade.  I'm getting mixed signals on 316 steel, some information and companies highly recommend it, some say its not recommended.  Any help would be appreciated.

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

The 30 deg C temperature would be no problem for 316SS, except you must consider the temperature of the heating media.  Hot water temperatures could be marginal for 316SS, and any steam temperatures would rule out the use 316SS for the hypochlorite solution (unless very low concentration).
I would suggest using a steam jacketed (or heat traced) teflon lined pipe to heat the solution, if there is a circulation loop from a pump.  You did not mention the vat's material.  Could the vat be heat traced?

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

(OP)
ApC2Kp,

Finally got some more information on the situation.

The vat is made of concrete, and is not a candidate for heat tracing.  The hypochlorite solution is 12%, and the heating media is going to be water, not steam.  Also, the heating coil will only be exposed to the solution for a week at a time, about four times a year.  

So you don't think the 316 SS will have corrosion problems with the NaOCl at 30 degrees?  I'm thinking that the limited exposure to the NaOCl will cause insignificant corrosion problems, but they don't want to have to replace the piping very often.

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

If you have problems, they'll be at the liquid/air interface.  And they'll depend entirely on your hot fluid temperature, since heat transfer conditions suggest that that the coil metal temperature will run closer to the heating fluid temperature than to the temperature of the hypochlorite solution in the vat.  If your coil's kept at 30 C, I doubt you'll have any problems if it's kept completely immersed- but by definition, that won't heat your tank to 30 C.  If your heating water is kept below 60 C, 316SS will probably last in your duty provided the coil exterior is cleaned after each week-long use.  Beyond 60 C, consider titanium, or a large teflon-coated coil.

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

Russiangoat,

Do NOT use SS with Hypochlorite.  It is exceptionally bad for that service.  Not only will it likely corrode in a week, but the metal contamination that it will cause in the Hypo will make the Hypo much more agressive as a stress cracking agent down the line in your piping, tanks, and pumps.

A PTFE coated coil is the best way to go and less expensive than using exotic alloys.

Glenn

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

This is a very interesting thread....

I am curious... Who has used and who makes these teflon coated coils and what are the operating limitations ???

Do these coils last very long and what is the primary market within the process chemical industry ???

Does anyone have any websites or weblinks that you can direct me toward ???

Thank You....

MJC

  

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

MJC,

There are several manufacturers for these types of products.  We have used the ones made by Process Technology. www.process-technology.com

How long the coil lasts is application dependent.  They are commonly used in metal finishing.

Glenn

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

(OP)
First I want to thank everyone for responding.

Second, the plant used to just paint some SS pipe they ran through the hypochlorite vat.  I want to know if anyone has opinions on whether painting the SS pipe would help prevent corrosion/metal contamination, or if that is just a band-aid solution.  Also, would metal contamination affect/damage the membranes being cleaned?

Third, I was wondering if Glenn, or anyone else, could tell me whether PTFE is usable with citric acid.  The plant would like to use a single pipe to heat both a vat of hypochlorite (for organic cleaning) and a vat of citric acid (for mineral cleaning), so if PTFE was going to be the only answer for the hypo, it has to work for citric acid too.

Thanks again for responses.

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

Russiangoat,

As you stated, painting the SS would be a bandaid solution.

Without knowing anything about the membranes, it is impossible to say if they would be damaged.  What type of pressure will they be subjected to?  What material are they constructed of?

PTFE should work just fine with a Citric acid solution.

Glenn

RE: heating coil material for use in Sodium Hypochlorite

Hi there

You should not use 316 ss to work with sodium hypochloride. It will attack the steel even at low temps. Try to use higher grade alloys such as Inconel 600 or even Monel 400. You'll seee the difference.
Cheers

Red Flag This Post

Please let us know here why this post is inappropriate. Reasons such as off-topic, duplicates, flames, illegal, vulgar, or students posting their homework.

Red Flag Submitted

Thank you for helping keep Eng-Tips Forums free from inappropriate posts.
The Eng-Tips staff will check this out and take appropriate action.

Reply To This Thread

Posting in the Eng-Tips forums is a member-only feature.

Click Here to join Eng-Tips and talk with other members!


Resources